[ ]   [ ]   [ ]                        [ ]      [ ]   [ ]
The Be Good Tanyas — Scattered Leaves
Album: Hello Love
Avg rating:
6.5

Your rating:
Total ratings: 1002









Released: 2006
Length: 4:40
Plays (last 30 days): 0
Don't you go looking so surprised, baby don't you look so stunned
Didn't I tell you that a cold november'd come?
And deliver the leaves from green to red,
To blowing in the wind stone dead

Well I never used to notice this awful quiet, mmmmh
And fall was just the calm before the next spring riot, mmmhh
Of wildflowers and lunatic rivers -
Sweat jumping off of the skin of love givers, mmh (in the park)

Scattered leaves don't lie
Aw' now baby, baby, quit your cryin'
Like everything that ever mattered, scit-scat scattered
Like every love word you heard
But that's just the way when you walk your days
In the beauty of this world
(repeat)

Pretty little disappointments all in a row
Been about a year since you disappeared through my door
And now you come back with your head on straight,
But I got no love or hate left for you, girl

You must be the daughter of the late, late rose - I'm November's son
And I'm here to tell you, honey, ooh what's done is done
Yeah, I been claimed by the wind and the rain
There ain't no going back, naw there ain't no going back again (for us now)

Repeat chorus -- Scattered leaves don't lie...
Comments (195)add comment
This seems like Jazz-Folk-Americana all in one. Great song  
just upped from 7 to 8 after re-reading the lyrics. It has been awhile since listening to the album and this is a wonderful post-love song...
Totally Cool!!!!
 sfyi2001 wrote:



 
                            Trish Klein                                             Frazey Ford                                                                                Samantha Parton




{#Crown} 
 

How can that photo be of them?  An old Rambler station wagon, hard sided luggage and vintage clothing.   Is it true?
Fantastic lyricism here and I love the quavering delivery.
It would be nice if there was a "appreciate the talent of the music but just not my cup of tea" level for rating songs.
 Thistle wrote:
Wow.... I was pouring over another boring document and all of a sudden I heard a voice that made me want to jam a pen in my ear.

Wasn't I amazed to learn that this time the voice didn't belong to Nathalie Merchant!

 
Sorry, but gotta ask, what were you pouring over the document and what's a pen?
 Ihatethissong wrote:


cool pic.  Thanks! (and the troop transport reference gave me a chuckle)
 

Beautiful... Love to hear more.... Thanks B & R
this is just plain good - that's the law and we must all respect the law ... nuff said, PEACE
The Be Goods are my guardian vagabond angels. 
 sfyi2001 wrote:



 
                            Trish Klein                                             Frazey Ford                                          Samantha Parton

{#Crown} 
 
 

cool pic.  Thanks! (and the troop transport reference gave me a chuckle)
Love the voice!!



Trish Klein, Samantha Parton, Frazey Ford




 
Her voice doesn't bother me at all, but I also like Beth Hart and Laura Love and Natalie Merchant.
I have to endure this-UGH! to get to the good stuff on RP {#Stop}
SWEET!
I will admit that her voice takes some getting used to.  But that banjo and the rest of the instrumentation is fabulous.
Might want to see a doctor about that, sounds painful.
 EssexTex wrote:
Nice song but she should swallow her Subway sandwich first
 

Man, this comment had me on the floor...

At least we've got her on the short list of potential replacement singers if Antony and the Johnsons break up.
 

Scary Good!
just enjoyed it.
ew. not liking this song...
Love her voice.
She has a solo album.


Gotta disagree with the flow here and say i think the voice is great.  The failure to sound like a homogeneous record industry drone is actually quite appealing to some.
I used to like TBGT but the goat thing got to me. Like Natalie Merchant.
 Thistle wrote:
Wow.... I was pouring over another boring document and all of a sudden I heard a voice that made me want to jam a pen in my ear.

Wasn't I amazed to learn that this time the voice didn't belong to Nathalie Merchant!

 

You know?!? I just had the same reaction! (But Natalie's OK).  I can't believe I ever rated this song a 2.  ugh. ear pain.


{#High-five}



While she sings like a female Ozzy, I must admit it has grown on me.  3 -> 5.
Why do they always sound like they are singing through a thick, woolen blanket?
Wow.... I was pouring over another boring document and all of a sudden I heard a voice that made me want to jam a pen in my ear.

Wasn't I amazed to learn that this time the voice didn't belong to Nathalie Merchant!

 Shesdifferent wrote:
Mouth full of marbles...TORTURE...sheer TORTURE!!!!!!
 

Station Changer - Ugh
Mouth full of marbles...TORTURE...sheer TORTURE!!!!!!
I keep trying to clear my throat for her. ai ai ai
Poignant
 EssexTex wrote:
Nice song but she should swallow her Subway sandwich first
 
Ha!
 Art_Carnage wrote:

Yes. And TBGT sound nothing like Maggie, Terre and Suzzy, either collectively or singly.
  Too bad there's no songs by the Roches at RP.  Can you upload?

 Excelsior wrote:


Don't apologize! It IS horrible!
 

Both of you should chill... Relax, enjoy. Sorry not everything fits into your sandbox..........
 Excelsior wrote:
This has to be some cruel joke.  To say the lead singer has no talent would be a severe understatement.  {#Puke}

 

I never need to check & see who this is when I hear this voice. Original, unique & all good.
 Excelsior wrote:
{#Puke}
 

Excelsior .... Chill Bud... Don't stress out

I never need to check & see who this is when I hear this voice. Original, unique & all good.
I never need to check & see who this is when I hear this voice. Original, unique & all good.

For anyone considering, this is a lovely album. And you can't beat the Prince cover on the hidden track! 
absolutely beautiful...unique vocals. lovely acoustic instrumentation.
wow....they be good them tanyas...

{#Clap}

I have always liked voices with some character and she certainly has it.   9.


I often like Be Good songs, but the singer's voice is so affected here. She's starting to sound like (say it isn't so) Natalie Merchant. Yikes.
{#Puke}
This is very very good and then some you!

This has to be some cruel joke.  To say the lead singer has no talent would be a severe understatement.  {#Puke}

I would like to like them more, but her voice annoys me.
Bakaretsu wrote:
Sorry but this is HORRIBLE!
Don't apologize! It IS horrible!
Bakaretsu wrote:
Sorry but this is HORRIBLE!
Each to their own... i quite like it :-)
I don't know what's with some people. I loves me some Tanyas.
Hannio wrote:
Ohmigod! Did she have a stroke? I think it is very brave of her to keep singing after such a debilitating affliction. Fie on all you naysayers!
Oooo. Cruel, but I also think her voice is a travesty.
StonedByte wrote:
can you say roches
Yes. And TBGT sound nothing like Maggie, Terre and Suzzy, either collectively or singly.
Huh, What did she say?
can you say roches
The comments are hilarious. I don't know why she annoys so many people. I just ordered this CD and I'm looking forward to it. I love the voice and vocal style.
Funny thing is that is what attracts me to her sound..ktnsb wrote:
She has an extremely distracting vibrato, or is it a tremolo? Regardless,it is something up with which I'd rather not put.
'nuff said.
Awesome!
middleagedhipster wrote:
Maybe somebody could upload another fine voiced Canadian like Celine Dion for all those who find this 'annoying'. These gals can come sing on my porch anytime.
Is that what the kids are callin' it these days? Dig them BGTs! c.
ah! bliss!
Ugh - how does this empart success onto the band - the lead singer gags the senses
Ohmigod!!! Did she have a stroke?? I think it is very brave of her to keep singing after such a debilitating affliction. Fie on all you naysayers!

Ugh. Her voice seriously makes me nauseated.
middleagedhipster wrote:
Maybe somebody could upload another fine voiced Canadian like Celine Dion for all those who find this 'annoying'.
S/he doesn't really mean that about Celine, heaven forbid! Just a little Canuck humour, eh? BTW - Have to ask: Are you a Chilliwack fan, middleagedhipster? Now if you uploaded some of that! (click here)
Can't stand the voice, it's like a chainsaw screaming in my brain.
Excelsior wrote:
I'm really hoping that one day, the talented part of the band will declare mutiny on the lead singer.
lmao. I can't agree with the sentiment, but that is a brilliant turn of phrase.
Heck, I'll even invite 'em inside. Great tune. middleagedhipster wrote:
Maybe somebody could upload another fine voiced Canadian like Celine Dion for all those who find this 'annoying'. These gals can come sing on my porch anytime.
Excelsior wrote:
I'm really hoping that one day, the talented part of the band will declare mutiny on the lead singer.
Amen. I have to rate this band lower each time I hear them. Music -> good. Singer -> hard to listen to.
Right on target, Liser.
liser wrote:
Foreign languages must be a pisser...
I am sorry. Is this Mubblish? Maybe Google can translate for me...
I like her sound, but not the mashing of the words.
sqqqrly wrote:
Different, but in a bad way. I can not understand what she is singing half the time, and that is usually a show stopper for me. A 3.
Foreign languages must be a pisser...
lokiwolf wrote:
Excellent sound! Too different for some commentators here, but just different enough to be unique and enjoyed.
Different, but in a bad way. I can not understand what she is singing half the time, and that is usually a show stopper for me. A 3.
Really good tune. Love the unique sound of the vocals.
Excellent, like practically all their output.
I'm really hoping that one day, the talented part of the band will declare mutiny on the lead singer.
cool song
Excellent sound! Too different for some commentators here, but just different enough to be unique and enjoyed.
stop that
Now you went and made me get up to reach for the mute button not to mention my barf bag!! Get those marbles out of your mouth!
marmelock wrote:
Heavenly!
Still true! Love the Tanyas ....
I'm thinking this group is like beer.. an acquired taste. Not bad, mind you, just an acquired taste.
Ggggggrrrrrraaaaaarghhhhhhh!
AAARRRRGHHHHH
Nice song but she should swallow her Subway sandwich first
hippiechick wrote:
I find it a bit annoying myself.
Ditto.
Maybe somebody could upload another fine voiced Canadian like Celine Dion for all those who find this 'annoying'. These gals can come sing on my porch anytime. hippiechick wrote:
I find it a bit annoying myself.
joshfm wrote:
for some reason when I hear these fine ladies sing and play it makes me want to roll in the hay, if you catch my drift.
FlatCat wrote:
Bill, it sounds like your turntable isn't holding its speed properly. Time for a new one. Oh wait... It's the quavering voice thing. Hard to listen to.
Agreed. She should stick to piano or something. Maybe someone punched her in the throat? Should have called themselves "The Shaky Tanyas"
didstanbul wrote:
This is a great song. She has such a unique voice.
I find it a bit annoying myself.
Just what I was going to say..excellent unique voice didstanbul wrote:
This is a great song. She has such a unique voice.
for some reason when I hear these fine ladies sing and play it makes me want to roll in the hay, if you catch my drift.
This is a great song. She has such a unique voice.
If it wasn't for RP I would have never heard of 'The Be Good Tanyas' or Neko Case. I love'em! And that more than makes up for Morphine, the yin to their yang.
Bill, it sounds like your turntable isn't holding its speed properly. Time for a new one. Oh wait... It's the quavering voice thing. Hard to listen to.
EniwaMan wrote:
No doubt about it, Frazey has a unique voice, and usually that means some love it and some hate it (see also: Neil Young, Bob Dylan, Natalie Merchant, John Hyatt, Tom Waits, and many others) There's no accounting for taste. I absolutely adore her voice. Love the Tanyas! To indulge in a cliché, she could sing the phone book and make it sound good. I understand the voice thing is a deal killer for people who don't like it, but there is so much more about this song to love: the groove, the melody, the lyrics.... It's a 10 for me.
Cliché away, my friend. I dig her voice too. c.
Loving it!!
last couple songs have an edge to them
Odyzzeuz wrote:
Don't understand why y'all are hatin' on this so bad. I think it's awesome.
Yeah, me too! Love the gals!
d00kie wrote:
ummmmmm....Yeah....NO *not so much*
Wow I just rated this song an 8 the other day! And then noticed that I posted this back in july... So within 3 Months of hearing something I wasn't exactly crazy about it has grown on me...Not sure if it is familiarity or if maybe I had a couple of glasses of wine and heard it at home relaxing compared to being in the office.
No doubt about it, Frazey has a unique voice, and usually that means some love it and some hate it (see also: Neil Young, Bob Dylan, Natalie Merchant, John Hyatt, Tom Waits, and many others) There's no accounting for taste. I absolutely adore her voice. Love the Tanyas! To indulge in a cliché, she could sing the phone book and make it sound good. I understand the voice thing is a deal killer for people who don't like it, but there is so much more about this song to love: the groove, the melody, the lyrics.... It's a 10 for me.
Reminds me of the coda to "Mind Games"... "I want you to make love, not war..." Did I just compare The Be Good Tanya's to John Lennon?
Shesdifferent wrote:
Yesterday, I had to sit through a grueling 3 songs from these warblers in one day! Enough already. Bury it!
well that explains your handle...
Me too! I really dig it. Actually, just ordered the CD online. Odyzzeuz wrote:
Don't understand why y'all are hatin' on this so bad. I think it's awesome.
marmelock wrote:
Heavenly!
Soul shattering.
Shesdifferent wrote:
Yesterday, I had to sit through a grueling 3 songs from these warblers in one day! Enough already. Bury it!
warblers, now that is a PERFECT description!
Heavenly!
I like it - a very chilling voice(s). Reminds me of the Roches.
Odyzzeuz wrote:
Don't understand why y'all are hatin' on this so bad. I think it's awesome.
Agreed. Most people have a narrow spectrum which limits their ability to get past any perceived irritating quality to 'hear' the rewarding parts. Myself included.
Odyzzeuz wrote:
Don't understand why y'all are hatin' on this so bad. I think it's awesome.
i think it's the voice and the fact that we have to hear it EVERY DAY!
Don't understand why y'all are hatin' on this so bad. I think it's awesome.
Can't stand the voices, really.
Yesterday, I had to sit through a grueling 3 songs from these warblers in one day! Enough already. Bury it!
handyrae wrote:
I agree. I really want to like them, but I just can't. I think it's the vocals--too nasal and with a real goat-like quality.
Bingo! A goat with a mouthful of hot potatoes. It's fingernails on a chalkboard time for me.
jt & the clouds.......jt & the clouds.......jt & the clouds.......jt & the clouds....... wrote this song....check out their album "Delilah" it's absolutely wonderful
ummmmmm....Yeah....NO *not so much*
buddyweiser wrote:
she should spit the hot potatos that she got in her mouth, sorry but i can't stand that garbage
and she should swallow the marbles dipped in peanut butter that are stuck in her throat
buddyweiser wrote:
not again
not again